Hamstrings train better with leg curls than with deadlifts

From Ergo Log

Training with free weights is generally better than training on machines, but there are always exceptions. If you want to develop your hamstrings, for example, you’ll make more progress by doing leg curls on a machine than doing stiff-legged deadlifts with a barbell. American sports scientist Brad Schoenfeld published an article about this in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning.

Study
Schoenfeld got 10 male students, all of whom had been doing weight training for a while, to perform stiff-legged deadlifts and leg curls while he measured the electrical activity in their hamstrings through electrodes he’d attached to their legs. The higher the electrical activity is, the more a muscle is working and the more growth stimuli it gets.

The researcher made a distinction between the lower and the upper hamstrings, and the medial and the latter hamstrings.

The lower hamstrings are above the knee joint and upper hamstrings are below the knee joint. The medial hamstrings are on the inside of your leg and later hamstrings are on the outer side of your leg.

Results
The leg curls [LLC] produced more electrical activity in the lower hamstrings than the stiff-legged deadlifts did [SLD]. The leg curls mobilised more muscle fibres in both the medial lower hamstrings and the lateral lower hamstrings than the stiff-legged deadlifts did.

For the upper hamstrings it made no difference whether the subjects trained them with the stiff-legged deadlift or with the leg curls.

The leg curls [LLC] produced more electrical activity in the lower hamstrings than the stiff-legged deadlifts did [SLD]. The leg curls mobilised more muscle fibres in both the medial lower hamstrings and the lateral lower hamstrings than the stiff-legged deadlifts did.

Conclusion
A few months ago we wrote about a similar study – but which had reached the opposite conclusion. In that study the subjects did not perform sets at failure; in this study they did.

Source:
J Strength Cond Res. 2015 Jan;29(1):159-64.

Source: http://www.ergo-log.com/hamstrings-l…deadlifts.html

 

Be Sociable, Share!

Leave a Reply

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *