Why Exclusionary Diets Like Paleo Are Problematic

eggs, chicken, vegetables and text paleo diet


Diets are a tricky—and often touchy—subject. Some swear by certain ways of eating, while detractors point to flaws in an eating strategy. Most recently, the Paleo diet seems to be getting all of the attention.


Many people have experienced extraordinary results after switching to a Paleo diet. And that’s fantastic! But for the vast majority of folks, exclusionary diets like Paleo often prove difficult to sustain in the long term.


Paleo Diet

Exclusionary—or elimination—diets limit or eliminate specific foods or food groups. According to PaleoPlan.com, the Paleo diet eliminates:

  • Legumes
  • Dairy
  • Grains
  • Grain-like seeds (e.g., quinoa)
  • Factory-farmed meats
  • Soft drinks and fruit juices
  • Sweets


Gone are any foods that our primitive ancestors couldn’t eat. They didn’t have the ability to process food, so they consumed only accessible foods in their most natural forms. Advocates of the Paleo diet think this is a healthier way to eat. Their logic makes sense.


However, our knowledge of food and nutrition has obviously grown since the days of the caveman. We have many, many more sources of food, and scientific research helps us make intelligent decisions about what we consume. It’s not just about survival anymore; it’s about optimizing health and performance.


That’s where exclusionary diets like Paleo come into question. Eliminating factory-farmed meats, soft drinks, fruit juices and sweets is a no-brainer for any healthy diet designed for performance and health.


But legumes, grains and quinoa? These are nutrient-dense foods that are widely considered among the healthiest foods available—and they’re hard to avoid in modern society. But Paleo eliminates them, promoting instead a diet high in meat consumption.


Yes, the Paleo folks can point to a study that supports their way of eating. But on the flip side, many studies, including the often referenced China Study, suggest that higher levels of animal protein consumption increase the risk of degenerative disease.


A case can be made that every diet—Paleo, gluten-free, vegetarian, vegan or anything else you can imagine—is exclusionary in some ways (although vegan diets are often exclusionary for ethical reasons).


Rather than getting wrapped up in the semantics of Paleo or whatever exclusionary diet that’s popular at the moment, maybe it’s time to open your mind to other schools of thought. There are many amazingly healthy foods, and arguably some should have a place in your diet.


That’s why Leslie Bonci, sports dietitian for several professional sports teams, advises taking an inclusionary approach with your diet, which she explains in the video above. The more healthy foods you can include, the better.


With that said, we can still learn a lot from the Paleo movement. Whether you’re an athlete or someone looking to improve your health, you should exclude factory-farmed beef, sugary beverages, sweets and highly processed foods. The less processing and refining, and the fewer ingredients, the better.


As Bonci says, a Paleo Plus mindset might be the way of the future.


Source: http://www.stack.com/a/why-exclusionary-diets-like-paleo-are-problematic?



Be Sociable, Share!

Leave a Reply

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *