Old-fashioned calcium HMB works better than HMB Free Acid, says rival

 

From Ergo Log

HMB Free Acid, the miracle supplement that enables bodybuilders to gain 7 kg hard muscle in a couple of months, is now available in webstores. And just as we were about to dig into our pockets to try and reduce the difference between ourselves and Phil Heath, researchers at Abbott Nutrition Research and Development publish a study which suggests we’re better off spending our money on the old-fashioned type of HMB. We see quarrels ahead. Goodie goodie.

HMB (2x)
HMB Free Acid goes by the name of BetaTOR in supplement jargon. It was created by Metabolic Technologies, and is found in MuscleTech’s Clear Muscle. The difference between this and the old HMB is that HMB Free Acid is an acid [formula below], and the old HMB is a calcium salt [formula above]. Click here for more on HMB Free Acid.

If the – sponsored – studies are to be believed, HMB Free Acid is about to put all steroids dealers out of work. They put this down to the superior bioavailability of HMB Free Acid compared with HMB Old ****.

Study
Researchers at the rivals Abbott Nutrition recently published a study in the Journal of Nutrition in which they had given rats both versions of HMB. They took into account that HMB Old **** contains calcium, so the rats got less (in grams) HMB Free Acid than calcium HMB per kg bodyweight.

Results
And hey presto! In the rivals’ lab not a trace of superior bioavailability was to be seen in the HMB Free Acid.

Explanation
“The stability of HMB in plasma was also tested, because unstable compounds tend to have a short half-life due to rapid clearance”, the researchers write. “However, both forms of HMB were found to be stable when incubated in plasma, demonstrating that the increased clearance of HMB Free Acid observed is not due to instability in plasma.”

“A structural analog of HMB, butyric acid, was demonstrated [Clin Chim Acta. 1989 May 31;181(3):255-63.] to undergo rapid oxidation after i.v. administration of 14C sodium salt, and liver was identified as the preferential site of uptake. Butyric acid demonstrated biphasic elimination pharmacokinetics in humans and rabbits, with a steep decline in concentration within the first 15 min, followed by a second phase of gradual elimination.”

“The elimination pharmacokinetics of HMB Free Acid mirrors that of butyric acid, with 50% of the administered dose being eliminated within the first 15 min. Given that the Vd of HMB Free Acid is higher than that of CaHMB, it is conceivable that HMB Free Acid partitions more rapidly into tissues. Whether the increased clearance of HMB Free Acid is due to increased tissue uptake and/or oxidation remains to be demonstrated.”

Conclusion
“A randomized crossover study (NCT01914952) is underway to understand the bioavailability of the 2 forms of HMB when both are given as a liquid supplement”, the researchers conclude. “The results of this study will provide further insights on the bioavailability of the 2 forms of HMB.”

Read more about the trial – financed by Metabolic Technologies – on clinicaltrials.gov. [NCT01914952] It was completed just a few weeks ago. No doubt we’ll be hearing more about it soon.

Source:
J Nutr. 2014 Oct;144(10):1549-55.

 

Be Sociable, Share!

Leave a Reply

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *